Ishaan Tharoor :For Israel, there's little political cost to killing Palestinians - The ...
This weekend in Gaza, Palestinians buried their dead after Israeli soldiers killed at least 18 Palestinian protesters and wounded hundreds more on Friday. About 30,000 Palestinians had gathered near the fenced barrier separating the Gaza Strip from Israel, both protesting the stifling blockade on their territory and mourning the dispossession of their ancestral lands at the hands of the Israeli state.
As in many
other Palestinian protests that take place in the occupied territories,
most protesters were unarmed and nonviolent. Families picnicked in the
shadow of the Israeli border and flew Palestinian flags. But like so
many other Palestinian protests, this one ended in tears.
“I took my grandchildren. We went to a peaceful demonstration,” Fayik Sabbagh told The Washington Post. “We went there to tell them this is our land, but what we found was different.”
Israeli
authorities claimed they opened fire in response to some protesters who
had encroached near the fence, burning tires and hurling stones or
molotov cocktails. Footage that emerged from the chaotic scene suggested
Israeli soldiers targeted unarmed protesters, including some who were
running away and were shot from a distance by snipers.
Israel’s defense minister rejected calls
April 1 for an inquiry into the killing of 15 Palestinians by the
military during a demonstration that turned violent.
One victim was 20-year-old Badr Sabbagh, Fayik’s son, who was killed just minutes after arriving
to watch the protests. “He asked for a cigarette, I gave it to him, he
had two puffs, and then he was shot in the head,” his brother Mohammed told The Post.
The
killings marked the worst day of violence in Gaza since the 2014 war
between the Islamist group Hamas and the Israeli military, in which the United Nations said at least 1,462 Palestinian civilians died.
And the aftermath of the protests underscored both the desperate
futility of the Palestinian struggle and the relative impunity with
which Israel can snuff out Palestinian lives.
The right-wing government of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu offered neither sympathy nor remorse.
“Israel is acting determinedly and decisively to protect its
sovereignty and the security of its citizens,” Netanyahu said. Officials
described the protest as a "camouflage" for Hamas infiltrators
supposedly launching an attack across the fortified border. Defense
Minister Avigdor Liberman rebuffed international calls for an investigation,
saying that “under no circumstances” would there be an inquiry into the
incident and opining that the Israeli soldiers manning the fence
“deserve a commendation.”
On
Saturday, the IDF even boasted that its troops had maintained total
control of the situation down to the number of bullets fired. But the
Israeli military soon deleted the tweet as more footage
surfaced of panicked Palestinians being gunned down while trying to
flee.
“These
are the predictable outcomes of a manifestly illegal command: Israeli
soldiers shooting live ammunition at unarmed Palestinian protesters,” said Amit Gilutz, a spokesman for B’Tselem,
a Jerusalem-based leftist organization that monitors human rights
abuses in the occupied territories. “What is predictable, too, is that
no one — from the snipers on the ground to top officials whose policies
have turned Gaza into a giant prison — is likely to be ever held
accountable.”
The Israeli leadership had reason to feel comfortable in its defiance. The most vocal criticism from abroad came from Iran and Turkey; censure from either country is more likely a source of relish for Netanyahu than unease. And at the United Nations, the Trump administration blocked the Security Council
from issuing a statement that called for an “independent and
transparent investigation” and affirmed the Palestinians’ right to
peaceful protest.
State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert said the United States was “deeply saddened” by Friday’s events. But Jason Greenblatt, Trump’s leading envoy for Israeli and Palestinian negotiations, undercut that message by taking Israel’s side and pinning the blame on Hamas for the “hostile march.”
Indeed, the Trump administration has helped stoke Palestinian outrage.
Across the occupied territories, Palestinian factions have called for
protests every day until May 15, “the day after the anniversary of
Israel’s independence in 1948, known to Palestinians as the ‘Nakba,’ or
catastrophe,” as my colleagues reported.
It also happens that the White House has chosen that date to open its
new embassy in Jerusalem, a move that reinforced the Palestinian view
that Washington can no longer be trusted as a fair broker in the long-stalled peace process.
Nor can the Palestinians look for much help from their neighbors. As we’ve discussed in this space, some of the region’s key powers — most notably Egypt and Saudi Arabia — have moved closer to Israel in recent years.
It has become clear that while the stateless Palestinians garner
tremendous sympathy from citizens across the Arab world, their plight
is a tiresome nuisance for some Arab leaders, who are more keen to crack down on Islamist parties at home or confront Iranian influence abroad.
The violence Friday should also be seen as another episode in the long-running power struggle between Hamas and the Palestinian Authority, led by Mahmoud Abbas. Attempts at reconciliation between the two factions have faltered,
and the two sides themselves have grown weaker. Abbas, the lost
shepherd of an all-but-dead peace process, has little chance of making
progress and perhaps even less credibility, while Hamas has been squeezed by both Israel and Egypt and has seen its sources of outside funding dry up.
All
the while, the ongoing blockade and restrictions imposed on Gaza have
made conditions more difficult for the Palestinians who live there. “I
want to be shot,” one 22-year-old protester told my colleagues on
Friday. “I don’t want this life.”
Israel’s heavy-handed response to the protest may now prove to be a propaganda coup for Hamas
— and a warning sign of further bloodshed to come. “If there isn’t a
major escalation of violence — especially with Palestinian leaders in
utter desperation playing with fire and Israel immediately resorting to
deadly force against unarmed demonstrators — it will be a political
miracle,” commentator Hussein Ibish wrote in the National, a newspaper based in Abu Dhabi. “But the ‘holy land’ rarely delivers such miracles.”
A
typo in an earlier version of this article incorrectly dated the
anniversary of the "Nakba" as an event in March. It is in May.
Want
smart analysis of the most important news in your inbox every weekday
along with other global reads, interesting ideas and opinions to know? Sign up for the Today's WorldView newsletter.
For Israel, there's little political cost to killing Palestinians - The ...
