Haaretz: sulla Pasqua di sangue di Toaff

-

Molto equilibrato il commento riportato su Haaretz del libro: "La Pasqua di sangue" di Toaff
In sintesi a un giudizio storico si risponde con un altro giudizio storico e, soprattutto, dopo aver letto il libro. Non è condivisibile l'attacco, più simile a una resa dei conti  ": un testo, per quanto discutibile agli occhi di molti, non può essere liquidato mettendo alla gogna gli autori e zittendo ogni ipotesi, anche scomoda, agitando i soliti "revival" : si ottiene l'effetto contrario demonizzando e non confutando . Così. più o meno consapevolmente, si fa il gioco dei veri antisemiti: la libertà di ricerca è un bene troppo prezioso e non si può identificare con la rozzezza espressa da certe ipotesi, contrabbandate per verità storiche, che girano in rete e non solo in rete

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/824152.html
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/827845.html

Commenti

Posta un commento

Post popolari in questo blog

giorno 79: Betlemme cancella le celebrazioni del Natale mentre Israele continua a bombardare Gaza

-
  Vittime Oltre 20.258 morti* e almeno 53.688 feriti nella Striscia di Gaza. 303 palestinesi uccisi nella Cisgiordania occupata e a Gerusalemme est Israele rivede il numero stimato delle vittime del 7 ottobre riducendolo da 1.400 a 1.147. 485 soldati israeliani uccisi dal 7 ottobre e almeno 1.831 feriti. Gaza guerra Hamas e Israele Sviluppi chiave Il presidente degli Stati Uniti Joe Biden non chiede al governo israeliano il cessate il fuoco nella Striscia di Gaza in una telefonata con il primo ministro Benjamin Netanyahu. Le forze israeliane si ritirano dalla rotonda palestinese di Gaza City dopo aver completamente raso al suolo e distrutto i locali che la circondano. Le squadre di soccorso palestinesi recuperano i corpi di 40 persone nel centro di Gaza uccise venerdì dai bombardamenti israeliani. L'esercito israeliano annuncia che 14 soldati sono stati uccisi in scontri armati con combattenti palestinesi nella Striscia di Gaza nel fine settimana. Un ministro israeliano afferma che...
Read more »

Shin Bet officers suspected of ordering unwarranted search of Palestinian woman's private parts ***

-
  Informazioni su questo sito web HAARETZ.COM Shin Bet officers suspected of ordering unwarranted search of Palestinian woman's private parts ***     Josh Breiner  and  Yotam Berger     Ex-Shin Bet chief on questioning of foreigners at Israel's borders: Shin Bet becoming a problem Shin Bet unit that probes alleged violations of suspects' rights operates without leader Claims against its agents mount, but Shin Bet opens no criminal inquests Shin Bet security service personnel are suspected of having told an Israel Defense Forces officer to order female soldiers to search a Palestinian woman’s private parts for no particular reason in an arrest three years ago in the West Bank. This was the first time the department for investigating complaints against  Shin Bet  opened a probe into allegations of violations of suspects’ rights during a Shin Bet interrogation. The...
Read more »

Gideon Levy :The IDF and Shin Bet, where falsehood is the faith and evil is conscience

-
The IDF and Shin Bet, where falsehood is the faith and evil is conscience haaretz.com Look who’s talking, and about what: The chief of staff of the Israel Defense Forces and the head of the Shin Bet security service are talking about “morals” and “ethics.” It’s like a slaughterhouse boss who dares to talk about animal rights, a prison warden who talks about freedom or the CEO of a cigarette company who talks about health. It briefly seemed as if Israel had finally woken up to hold a real debate on this summer’s war in the Gaza Strip. After all, Chief of Staff Benny Gantz wrote in his letter to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu about a “moral and ethical fault” and about the Shin Bet’s having “crossed all moral and ethical lines.” But this sanctimonious poesy was of course devoted to the ridiculous pissing contest over the Gaza war between Gantz and Shin Bet chief Yoram Cohen, two manly men. A generals’ war always erupts when it becomes clear that the v...
Read more »

Haaretz : In the U.K. and in Israel, a Shift Toward Ultranationalist Isolationism

-
            In the U.K. and in Israel, a shift toward ultranationalist isolationism Unlike the British, Israel doesn’t need a referendum to declare its disengagement from Europe and the West. It's well on its way. haaretz.com    The shock caused by the British public’s decision to leave the European Union is still fresh. The fall of the world’s stock markets and the resignation of Prime Minister David Cameron are just the beginning of a long and tortuous separation whose consequences cannot yet be assessed. Is the entire EU on the brink of disintegration? Will Britain itself continue to be the United Kingdom? What are the vote’s implications for international coalitions — those bound by free trade agreements and those formed in order to wage war on terror? At this point, all that can be done in the face of these portentous musings is to examine the reasons for the decision to leave. The direct cause was ...
Read more »